Steve and Jaime Polter host open house in remodeled downtown Port Clinton building

Oct 28, 2026 | Business | 1 comment

Dozens of people attended the Community Open House Celebration to view the short-term rentals and Steve and Jaime Polter’s private living space at 106 W. Second St. in Port Clinton. Here, guests lounge in the Polter’s home. (Photo by Sheri Trusty)

BY SHERI TRUSTY

PORT CLINTON – While some people host housewarming parties to welcome friends to their new homes, no one invites the entire community – except for realtors Steve and Jaime Polter. After finishing a three-year remodeling project on the second and third floors of their building at 106 W. Second. St. at the corner of Second and Madison streets in downtown Port Clinton, they invited the whole town to see it during a Community Open House Celebration on Oct. 20.

The building houses business offices on the first floor, short-term rentals on the second floor, and the Polters’ own residential space on the third. The dozens of people who attended the open house didn’t just see the rentals. They were also invited into the Polters’ third floor home, an exquisite space that melds homey comfort with upscale aesthetics. It is a home where guests feel at ease in a glamorous atmosphere.

Jaime and Steve Polter stand in the kitchen of their downtown Port Clinton home during the Community Open House Celebration on Oct. 20. (Photo by Sheri Trusty)

The project adds one more reason for Port Clinton to be proud of its downtown. Madison and Second streets are lined with late 19th century buildings that hold stories of the town’s rich history, and projects like the Polter building renovation fuse the past with the future, bringing the buildings into a new era of lakeshore living.

“It was really important that we do this the right way. We didn’t gloss over problems to quickly put it back into use,” Jaime said. “We see this building as a community fixture. We did this for the community, and I wanted others to see this is possible.”

This living room in one of the three short-term rentals in the Polters’ building lets in sunlight and views of downtown Port Clinton. (Photo by Sheri Trusty)

The second floor features three one-bedroom, short-term rentals, which have already hosted over 600 guests this year, and the third floor Polter home includes two bedrooms; an expansive, modern kitchen; and a dining room and living room with big picture windows that let in sunlight and views of downtown activity.

Jaime designed the entire two-floor space. The building was constructed in 1896 as a bank, and Jaime designed the second and third floors in vintage chic, giving a nod to the building’s glory days during Prohibition.

“I just wanted it to feel like its era, like the speakeasy era,” she said.

Steve said the walls were covered with plaster, which was removed to expose the brick underneath, adding a layer of trendy comfort to the rooms.

Steve and Jaime Polter completely remodeled the second and third floors of their building at the corner of Second and Madison Streets in downtown Port Clinton, creating short-term rentals and the Polters’ private living space. (Photo by Sheri Trusty)

“We gutted the building,” Steve said. “It has new electric, plumbing, heating, and cooling, and we added an elevator. We put in a new ceiling. Pretty much everything you look at, we put in.”

One element of the project is on hold – repairing the vintage clock on the outside of the building that is a landmark in downtown Port Clinton. Repair costs prohibited immediate attention.

“It will cost $30,000 to repair. We would love to eventually have a community fundraiser,” Jaime said. “It’s another difficult task, but we have every intention of fixing it.”

The entire building renovation project, including the rentals and private residential space, was “99.9%” privately funded. No public funds were used.

“We’re so proud about what we did with this building. It will still be here for the community in 70 years,” Jaime said.

For more information on the short-term rentals, visit www.blamejaime.com.

Related Post 

1 Comment

  1. Ann

    Is there an elevator in the building? My husband & I visit Port Clinton frequently from Miamisburg. We are both elderly and cannot do stairs.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Webify Ohio

Calendar

November 2026
SMTWTFS
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930 






Share This